"Dust if you must but I believe, a house becomes a home when you can write "I Love You" on the furniture"

My childrens friends step into our home breathing in the air, anticipating the aroma of goodies baking in the oven; More often than not, It's Brownies!


CHEAP AND YUMMY BROWNIE RECIPE!

6 TBSP cocoa, 1/4 C butter, 1 C sugar, 1/2 tsp vanilla, 1/3 C flour, 2 eggs, Cook 350 - 25 mins.

10/12/09

THE DEFINITION OF HOMESCHOOLING or AFTERSCHOOLING IS NOT HOMESCHOOLING! (Please! Get it right!)

A friend told me recently that she is "homeschooling" her children after school. She told me they are doing something called "Afterschooling." I was taken aback by this revelation and believed her to be very confused.


Two weeks later, I was told by another parent, that they "homeschool during the summer." I gasped inside and probably, inadvertently, gave quite the scowl and indignant look.


I tried to recover my usual relaxed emotional state, however their comments....the very idea that they could even THINK that they are homeschooling...is beyond my ability to grasp. Their idea of what homeschooling is, is so flawed that I realized quite quickly that a definition for homeschooling is not only needed, it is demanded! I am here to set the record straight!


We don't "Do" Homeschool. We ARE Homeschoolers. Our children ARE homeschooled! Homeschooling is NOT done...It is Lived!!


------------------




I will tell you right now that what those two parents are doing doesn't even belong in the same zip code as homeschooling. They may wish they were homeschoolers, but the reality is that they are not.


Is a homeschooler educated at home? Yes. Are all people who learn at home, homeschoolers? No. Because, homeschooling is a lifestyle.


HOMESCHOOLING: HOMESCHOOL: HOME SCHOOL:

Dictionary.com meaning
:
to teach one's children at home instead of sending them to school.

This is a nice beginning description but I must elaborate on this condensed, sterile definition.

Homeschooling is not only the act of teaching our child at home, but about the responsibilities parents and their family accept when we do not send them to a traditional school. We live a very different life than those who choose the traditional road. It begins with the choice to brave the legal hurtles and continues through the tears of worry and the triumphs of success. Homeschooling is about the road the entire family is traveling. We, as a Homeschooling Family, accepted the reality of our choices and live with the good, bad and the ugly that result from that choice.



There are some (not all) parents who blame the public school system when their child fails in a subject. There are some parents who take all the credit when their child succeeds. Homeschooling parents have only ourselves to blame either way.

We have the full weight of all the successes and failures on our shoulders; no matter what. ALL homeschooling parents have to carry this load. All of us. We can’t in any way, shape or form, be let off the hook. We are scrutinized more and judged more often than those who send their children to school. That is the lifestyle of a homeschooler.


The idea that my mother “homeschooled” me when she helped me with my homework is laughable, but there are some who believe that every parent who helps their child with homework is homeschooling. However, their children, unlike their wishful thinking parents, know whether they are homeschooled children or public/private schooled children. 
If someone were to ask the kids where they go to school they would say, Roosevelt or wherever. A traditionally educated child knows they have to go to school, sit, learn, then come home and sit, learn more. 


To them, “homeschooling” may be a pain in the hiney because it’s above and beyond their “other” schooling lives.  It is supplemental to their “real” education. “Real” meaning the day long life they lead away from home; the reality of their educational lives. Until the child is actually homeschooled they know they are actually Public Schooled children or Private Schooled children. They live it. They are being educated at school and enduring yet more forced work as a "supplemental" education at home.

I can see how the idea of homeschooling full time would make some parents uneasy. I’ve been there. I’m thinking that maybe these baby steps are how they allow themselves to warm up to the idea of actually jumping into the home education world. It’s a process of sorts like…Maybe if they say to themselves, “Ah, see, I’m homeschooling right now as I help with homework so maybe I can teach a subject.” Then they buy a bible class or history curriculum and teach that after homework and say to themselves, “See now I’m actually teaching from a book so maybe I can go on and think about taking the kids out of school” Then they think, “ Oh my goodness, no I can’t do that, that’s crazy so maybe I’ll just do it during the summer” and then they see that they can do it during the summer so one day they all of the sudden feel empowered and jump! Voila! Process Complete!

All of those ways allow the parent to “homeschool” gently (in their mind) in their home while coming to terms with whether they are capable (in their minds) of homeschooling full time. I understand the want and even the need to say the words, “I’m homeschooling.” It becomes a familiar word that the parent can “own” so they can eventually create the reality in their home. However, while they may indeed be on the road to homeschooling, they are NOT a homeschooling family or even homeschooling at all.



In those instances the family is "playing house" if you will. They are pretending to homeschool. They are hoping to homeschool. They are going through the motions of the mechanics of homeschooing but they are not yet homeschooling. They don't know what it means, how it feels or how they will be treated when they ARE homeschooling. They won't know until they ARE a homeschooling family.
 

Are "afterschoolers" learning at home? Yes. Are they “Homeschooled Children?” No. They are Public or Private schooled children who have parents teaching them above and beyond their traditional schooling. Their parents are educating them, as any parent should, but they are not homeschooling. They are teaching them, reading to them, helping their children along with their lives. They are parenting. They are helping to supplement the education they've chosen for their children. That's it. That is a beautiful family choice and great parenting, but they are not homeschoolers and they are not homeschooling.

The difference between a homeschooler and a private/public educated child is that homeschooled children are living a different life than the average bear.  Homeschooled children are living their lives outside of an institutional setting. They do not sit in classrooms with a group of children and learn from a teacher. Homeschoolers learn at home, all the time….whether physically at home or on various outings…they are home. 



Their lives are completely different than a traditionally educated child. A homeschooled child knows that their lives are very, very different than a public/private schooled child. If you ask a homeschooler where they go to school they will say, "I AM homeschooled." They won't say, I homeschool! They ARE homeschoolers. Homeschooling is so much more than being tutored. It is more than having a parent sit with their child to teach. Parents who do this are wonderful parents…but they are not homeschooling parents. 


Homeschooling is about our lives as a family unit being untouched by the confines of those that would impose their rules on our family. We are able to move freely through our lives without checking our calendar to meet an institution time-table.  Homeschooling is a pronouncement of difference, acceptance and pride. Homeschooling is freedom! 


For a parent to say they are a homeschooler or are homeschooling, when they are sending their children to private or public school is unsettling to those of us who live the lifestyle because they are assuming that homeschooling is something that is done.They assume that our lives are not very different when, in fact, our lives are so very different. I am not saying we are better. I am, however, saying we are different. It is respectful to acknowledge that fact. 


We are educating our children, full time, without a safety net handily in place each day. We took on the responsibility and we deserve to claim the name of Homeschooler! We will NOT give that name to every parent who opens a book and reads to their child. We are so much more than that! We do that AND everything the school does for those wishful thinking parents. Until you do it ALL, you are NOT homeschooling...you are parenting.  Please, Acknowledge the difference.



Homeschooling is not done. It is lived!

16 WHAT'S YOUR TWO CENTS?:

Dawn @ Coming to a Nursery Near You said...

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this post! Thank you for putting into words what Homeschool TRULY is.

Sassy Mama Bear said...

BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!! Well said.

Kristina said...

Ah, the afterschooling crowd. I've actually run into this quite a bit over the last few years. This, it seems, is what the NEA would have us do with our children when they are failing in school. That way, they can have the "whole" school experience. You might as well take them to Sylvan and get them tutoring. After all, that IS what you are doing.

That's not to say you're not helping. Certainly, my dad taught me a LOT. But, he wasn't homeschooling me (except for that one semester in 7th grade, which was totally different from the rest of the time, when he was, quite frankly, just being a dad.)

ourhomesteadingquest said...

Someone sent me the link to your blog today and I'm glad they did. I bookmarked your blog to my favorites. I loved this post and the definition of homeschooling! So true.

I hear afterschooling a lot with people who are being convicted to home school but because of outside pressure or the fear of failure (or just the unknown) they make excuses for why they could never home school...although they would love to?

Although, I'll be the first to admit that homeschooling is NOT for everyone. However, if you're willing to stick with it through the good times and the bad (just like with your marriage) it will be one of the most rewarding (and challenging) experiences of your life.

Scrapingirl said...

AMEN!!!! It's called being a parent and helping your child do their homework. Or those with 3 yr olds telling us they homeschool. NO!! You are being a parent, preparing them for school. AUGHH!!!

Eevee said...

I'm a first time reader on your blog :)

Although this is a few days late I would like to say that I definetly agree with you. These parents are being misguided by resources out there such as:

A to Z Homes Cool Homeschooling

Article: Just for the Summer
Article: Single Parent and Working

I'm a bit bothered with what I just read about "Summer is a great time to see if you could enjoy the "unschooling" life style.

I'm a Christian Unschooler and just as you pointed out its not a Hummm...During summer we'll call ourselves Unschoolers and then off you go to school once September rolls around.

I can see how some parents might be mislead to believe the are homeschooling their children.

Blessings,
Eevee

G4 and Sharkgirl said...

I am not a homeschooler - I am actually a public school teacher - but I <3 homeschoolers and think what you do is awesome. I enjoy getting ideas from homeschoolers that will work in my classroom; and thank my knowledge of different homeschooling methods for making a much better teacher.

I agree that afterschooling is not homeschooling; likewise I would be horrified if students were forced to sit through a mountain of worksheets after school in the name of afterschooling. (Of course I am the teacher who doesn't know for a week that the photo-copier is broken, so I guess that shows how I feel about worksheets LOL I hate homework too, so I am really a freak as a teacher).

HOWEVER, as a public school teacher I laughed at the comments who said afterschooling is good parenting and nothing more. Yep - they are correct, but as a teacher I see the problem as this - a huge problem in education is that many parents are not doing this type of parenting. This is something I think of more and more each school year.

Obviously, you and most of your readers don't see the need for something like afterschooling - and I can TOTALLY see how it would feel like an attack on your lifestyle or even almost saying what you do is so minor I can do it at home after "real school."

Coming from the other side of the fence - educating some whose parents haven't ever stepped foot in the school building - if there was a connection between school and home that would be great. Not in the form of flashcards (bleh), but in the real experiences that homeschoolers do so well and public school has such a hard time with.

Anyway, thanks for the added thoughts in some thinking I am doing about public education and the direction it is heading and where I think it should be headed. We have a real opportunity as a country to make some very cool changes, but we won't . . . sigh.

Shannon said...

Hi, I commented on one of your recipe posts a few minutes ago, and thought I should introduce myself so you don't think I'm some weirdo internet lurker. (I can be weird, but not in a creepy way.) :) I'm Shannon.

This is my first year to school my children at home; I have a daughter in first grade, a daughter in kindergarten (my schoolers), and then 2 boys, ages 3 and 6 months. I wanted to respond to this post simply because I've been on both "sides" of this education thing, felt the pressure on both "sides" from both "sides," and (I'd like to think) grown through these experiences and come to see more clearly both perspectives.

I loved the comment left by the public school teacher; so few parents are active and engaged in their children's education that it's become normal to think of any involvement or enrichment as a form of homeschooling. Certainly, it's not at ALL the same as what you are living. I was one of the involved parents in the public school last year...because that's what I believe being a good parent entails. God has charged ME (and my husband) with the education of our children...not the teachers or schools or state or nation. Part of parenting is ensuring that my children have what they need to become God-following, well prepared, thinking, productive individuals. And that type of involvement is certainly a different style of life than what I'm living this year.

So, I agree with the content of what you are saying.

However, because such a battle line exists between all the various schooling choices, (and this is spoken from someone who has posted things on her own blog of a ranting nature and lived to regret the tone) without care and compassion (on BOTH "sides"), NO understanding will be reached.

It is, indeed, a respect issue.

Naturally, this is your space to share your thoughts, and you shouldn't have to "kiss up" to people...I'm just saying that people of other perspectives who might encounter your post would bristle, not because of the content, but because of the tone.

I hope that doesn't come accross as a lecture; I certainly don't intend it that way. I've only just found your blog (through a friend of mine), so I don't know much about your writing style or intent; but I would've loved if someone had kindly told me something like this a year or so ago before I posted some things that inadvertantly hurt people's feelings. :)

Love the great way your blog is laid out and all your wonderful ideas. Enjoy your weekend!

Author said...

I carefully worded this post in the hope that the truth would come out, all the while acknowledging that those who "wish" they homeschooled will probably NOT want to understand the truth about their choices.

If the tone is abrasive to you, it may be that you are one who hopes to homeschool, but can't? It is in that mindset that my tone...ie: the truth could cause irritation. If you are not that person, I don't see how this post could annoy you in the least.

I don't apologize for my words. I meant them and stand by the truth of my post.

Shannon said...

I never said I was annoyed. I just think it's helpful to be kind instead of sounding like you have an axe to grind. Your blog, your opinion. Naturally. :)

Tiffany said...

I've read through this post a few times now and there's really only one question I have for you. Why do you care?

I mean, I have a 4-yr old son who goes part-time to pre-school, but I also do workbooks (far beyond what he's doing in "school") at home with him. I don't claim to be a "homeschooler" and I probably won't "homeschool" him unless that proves to be the best for OUR family. I could care less what people think or say about whether my son will/will not attend public/private school. If you are SO confident in your status as a homeschooling family (whose son still attended a public school - even if just one year), as you seem to be, then why does it matter what someone else thinks they do? I teach my son many things, but don't claim to be a teacher. I cook gourmet meals on occasion but don't claim to be a chef.

Point is, nobody is better than anyone else because of what they do or don't do, so why act like if you aren't a homeschooler, you are crap? It'd be a nice change to give credit where it's due because obviously in today's society, fulfilling the "appropriate parental role" is not always the way things go.

The MWB said...

Hello Tiffany,

"Giving credit where credit is due" is exactly what this post is about.

There are moments in our homeschooling lives when friends or acquaintances, (who usually don't approve of our choice to homeschool) will "poo poo" our lifestyle by stating that they do the same thing.

I have the ability to voice the difference to my associates in person, however, some people still don't understand what the difference is "exactly." This post states the difference.

You will notice that I am careful to point out that homeschooling parents are not better; They ARE Different.

Allowing a child to go to public school is fine and dandy also. As you pointed out, we have used that option in our household.

Again, re-read the post please.

This post is directed toward parents who "feel like" they are homeschooling their children by teaching them at home while sending them to school at the same time.

That is not homeschooling. Those families are NOT homeschooling families. They are NOT doing the same thing we do.

I hope that clarifies my point.

"It'd be a nice change to give credit where it's due" because homeschooling is a challenging lifestyle. Acknowledging that fact is respectful. Assuming that all parents homeschool is radically incorrect.

LibrarianMom said...

I am an afterschooler. I don't say and would never say I homeschool as I understand that homeschooling is an all ecompassing 24/7 endeavor. Yet I feel you vastly underestimate the intentionality with which many individuals afterschool their children, the reasons why they may choose to do so, and the things they may give up in order to do so. Just as you would ask someone not to judge you based on your decision to homeschool, please do not judge those of us who choose to afterschool.

The MWB said...

Hello LibrarianMom,

I've stated that Afterschooling is Not Homeschooling.

I've stated that parents who say they are "Afterschooling and do the same thing as homeschooling" are misguided and incorrect.

I have taken issue with those who assume they are homeschooling just because they teach their children in the hours above and beyond their child's public/private school hours.

I've stated that those who choose to enrich their child's education when the public/private school doors close are wonderful parents.

I have not judged people who teach their children after the school day is finished. I've only pointed out that it is NOT Homeschooling.

I stand by my post, my words and my thoughts.

We ALL give up "things" for our children, whether we homeschool or send them to a private/public school.

We all intentionally teach our children "things" when the public/private school doors close.

No matter how intentional you are about their before school, after school, summer school studies...It's NOT homeschooling. It's good parenting...(if it doesn't wear the poor kid out.)

The POINT IS...

Afterschooling is NOT Homeschooling....ever.

No Judgment...Just Stating the Truth.

burckeri said...

"The POINT IS...

Afterschooling is NOT Homeschooling....ever."

But afterschoolers and homeschoolers can share and learn a great deal from each other. I would prefer to keep a friendly and respectful relationship between the two groups. That relationship is not helped by comments such as this, by one of your readers:

"You might as well take them to Sylvan and get them tutoring. After all, that IS what you are doing."

Umm, no. That is NOT what I'm doing. I'm not just helping him with his homework and I'm not tutoring him. I'm teaching my son concepts and skills well before he encounters them in school. I've invested countless hours in researching curriculum materials and reading and responding to messages from others in the homeschooling/afterschooling community. What I do with my son is above and beyond "good parenting". In a very real sense, I'm providing my son's main education and using school to supplement, rather than the other way around. I teach reading, math, social studies, and science in addition to doing read-alouds, with a little handwriting and French practice thrown in. He attends a French-language school, which is giving him the opportunity to become truly bilingual, something he wouldn't get if he were homeschooled.

I'm not a wannabe homeschooler. I have chosen afterschooling as the best choice for my son and our family at this point. I respect homeschoolers and realize that their experiences are different from afterschoolers, but I think homeschoolers should accept afterschoolers as being on the spectrum of parent educators and not try to drive a wedge between themselves and afterschoolers.

The MWB said...

Buckeri,

"I'm providing my son's main education and using school to supplement, rather than the other way around."

I'm not pulling ANY punches with you here, Buckeri.

You are harming your child. His soul is breaking inside, just TRYING to please you. He is spending his beautiful childhood hours obediently serving your whims and trying so very hard to live up to your "standards." I bet he does it with a smile and hugs you and loves you.

People who are pushed this hard after 7 hours of school do have nervous breakdowns.

Whether you know it or not, he is trying to please you and going to great lengths to make you happy...at the expense of his childhood.

Your child's mind has to be reeling! "Tomorrow I work hard. The next day I work harder. The next day I work and I study and I go to another class. My mother and my father need me to be great. They need me to be important. They need me to do good so they can be proud. I have to work harder, harder...I must do better!"

I have no tolerance for this kind of "parenting." You have NO IDEA how much your child just wishes to please you.

HE JUST WANTS YOU TO SAY (AND MEAN) THAT YOU LOVE HIM EVEN IF HE BECOMES A HOUSE PAINTER!!! TELL HIM YOU ARE PROUD OF HIM NO MATTER WHAT GRADES HE GETS!!! YOU LOVE HIM BECAUSE HE IS THE BIGGEST BLESSING IN YOUR LIFE REGARDLESS OF HIS ACADEMICS!!! WHO CARES IF HE'S BILINGUAL....UGH!

You seriously need a child development class to educate YOURSELF on the harm you are doing to your child.

You are sucking up the precious time of his childhood to have him live up to YOUR fantasy goal. What does HE want? You won't know because NOW he KNOWS WHAT YOU WANT!! He has NO CLUE what he wants OTHER THAN TO PLEASE YOU!! He will want to do what you tell him just so you love him!!!

Even when he's playing, he is burdened, thinking, worrying about this grade or that class!

You are burdening your child with so much stress that he WILL break in the future and all hell is going to break loose in his psyche and your life.

It is AFTERSCHOOLING pressure, NEEDLESSLY placed on children, that can break a child to pieces.

Lest you object: THERE IS NO ARGUMENT TO BE HAD HERE. You Are Doing Harm!

What a waste of his youth. Where is his down time?

----------------------

I hesitate to even touch on the ridiculous statement that homeschooled children cannot be bilingual. We DO have co-ops and education opportunities that allow our children to TRULY become bilingual. If YOU can find the time to fit it into your poor child's schedule, why in the world would we have a hard time fitting it in?

I hope your child helps you keep up with the Jones'. As for my house, we homeschool to be together, to play together, to learn together. We homeschool to be a FAMILY. We homeschool to BOND.

Our eldest son turned 18 years old this month. He's earned his associate degree from college. He was 17 when he walked for that degree. He did it BECAUSE HE WANTED TO!!!!!

Our next son in line is thinking about it. He may choose another route for his life and that's totally fine. He's healthy and loving and we are so very blessed to call him our son....even if he's not bilingual and his spelling is atrocious.

I hope this is your wake-up call kiddo. You can rant in the comments all you want, but if this keeps you up at night and gets even one "class" off your child's heart, so be it. Rant all you want. Call me names. Hate homeschoolers. You name it. Just play with your kid and give him a break. He wants your time and needs a childhood.

 
ss_blog_claim=6ccf5bd46c4750bbd1efb1264188e87b ss_blog_claim=6688b427078c5dcb2a0244287f89d371